Seasonally Employed Ghosts and the Scottish Tim McGraw Homo-cidal Birdman and the Confessions of Shauna K. Horse Grunts and the 1900s Policeman Who Was Also a Scarf Personįlo & Frankenstein and Christine Has Another StrokeĪn Even Worse Eyeball Story and the Adventures of Captain MidnightĪ Great View of the DMV and There's No Such Thing as a Fun Best Friend Murder *įun Times in the Body Chute and Em's Hairy Torsoįour Pounds of Uneaten Bacon and A Deeply Holy-Some Blonde The Old School House of Pies and Freud's Field DayĪ Sample of Our Outhouse and Catfished by Lucifer The Cincinnati Mobsters and a PSA for Samsung The 300-Year-Old Drama Queen and the Bitchy 7th Grader
The Wandering Cowboy and the Pregnancy Pact, but for BoysĪnnabelle the Doll-y Parton Impersonator and the Tap Water ScammerĪ Drunk Pandora's Box and How to Play the Elevator Game The Human Hair Version and the Worst Social Studies Class EverĪ Menorah Made of Lava and the Jerry Springer of Germany The "Creepy Little Thing" and a Journey of Self-Destruction Paranormal Bitchslaps and the Body Examiners Schieffer returned to the show in mid-February 2022.Įpisodes Regular Show Episodes Regular Show Episodesįrances Ford "Cupola" and the Off-Brand Kool-AidĬlothesline Cookies and the Lone Band-Aid
During that time, Schulz continued to host the show along with a series of guest hosts, including Eva Gross and Schulz' life partner Allison Goforth. In October 2021, Schieffer took maternity leave after giving birth to her first child. On the first day of every month, the show features a special episode of "Listener Stories", in which the hosts read and react to stories of crimes and the paranormal submitted by fans, often with a theme requested by one of the hosts.ĪTWWD occasionally features special guests, including the hosts' family and friends as well as comedian Lisa Lampanelli, who is Schiefer's aunt-in-law, and the podcast has done several crossover episodes with podcasts such as Wine and Crime, Morbid, and Sinisterhood, among others. While this is still a way for the hosts to identify their respective fan bases (more recently including a Team Lemon ), in later episodes of the show, the practice of drinking milkshakes was mostly abandoned. Originally, the two hosts also divided themselves into "Team Wine" and "Team Milkshake," as Schiefer often imbibes alcoholic drinks during the recording sessions, while Schulz, a teetotaler, would drink a variety of milkshakes, and the two would list the reasons (both good and bad) they were drinking that episode. The original name of the show was "Eerie in Theory", but was changed later in the conception phase to "And That's Why We Drink", after it was jokingly exclaimed during a moment of exasperation. The two friends often tell stories about their lives as well, occasionally adding personal anecdotes to the stories.
This is followed by Schiefer's true crime portion of the show in which she covers murders, serial killers, unsolved crimes, and abductions.
The first is the paranormal section, in which Schulz discusses a paranormal story, often dealing with suspected haunted locations, alien or UFO sightings, cryptids, and occasionally conspiracy theories or creepypastas.
The podcast is formatted into two sections.